I suspect that some of those little 'pointers' in kata [to open the hips], may be considered errors by some of the Old School. Yet unless we are open to new ideas how can we ever expect make progress?
Once you understand the art to a high degree and actively go out to seek the answers, the masters (the real ones) love that you go ahead and make changes. You've already respected the art. Naka-sensei, I feel has already achieved that to a high degree. Some purists don't know what they're doing and that's why they're stuck in "tradition." With unrealistic training expectations and whatnot.
In this video series, I think that Naka Sensei wanted to show open-mindedness when encountering other styles. He is, of course, tremendously polite and respectful. It’s one thing to open the hip up (change the foot angle) when one is about to step forward into z-d, whereas when stepping laterally and landing in kiba-dachi then changing the foot angle would just require changing it back when one landed...
M Cron Truth be told, the “old school” referred to by Bill is nothing more than a rebranding of the original. Many of the ways we THINK are old school techniques are shallow and new inventions. Yoko-Geri keage, as a sokutou-geri for example? Never done by Funakoshi-sensei. But his students started doing it for training purposes instead of the original, which was the open-hips front-kick to the side, and it stuck
I do think, it is an error indeed. From a Bunkai POV, you MUST turn on the ball, as there is not enough space to open the hip. The opponent is not miles away. You are litteraly glued to him in that moment. The Kata has 3 movements because it wants to show you the transition from right to left, then from left to right. Naka-sensei has a very bad habit of wanting to apply Kata to Kumite.
In kumite competition, we will forget any those technic. In kumite competition everyone is just punching each other, dont care about the beautiful movement of Karate. Only in Kata we can enjoy the beautiful movement of Karate including. You can say, "Kata can also used in fight"? Really? Just look at back the Kumite competition video all around the world!
Kumite Competition has little to do with Kata. You could say that you can enter Kumite Competition with the Kata knowledge of a yellow belt easily. That's because Kata is ment for self defence, which has a completely different movement range than Competition Kumite.
Comment se casser le dos en pratiquant les katas, en plus pour ne pas être efficace... C'est vraiment triste de voir un haut gradé japonais montrer ca.
ここまで一流の人が未だに研究を怠らず研鑽を続けている事に頭が下がる思いです。
まさに求道者…尊敬します
この映像、何年経って廃れようか。いや廃れない。先ずもって、美しい。
カッコ良すぎる
Thanks for the subtitles. Great tips from Naka Sensei
one of my favourite katas of all time
I love this, and also I'm a fan of Tatsuya Naka. He is also a chief instructor of J.K.A.(Japan Karate Association). I'm also learning shotokan JKA.
Thank you so much for the subtitles!!! This is so helpful!!!! :D
『技のトリセツ』DVD届きました！DISC1は『大いなる遺産』の「特典映像:空手講座」と『未来への宝物』の”基本一本””自由一本”や井上先生との虚実でついていけましたが、DISC2の鉄騎初段は空手未経験者には歯応えがありますね。この動画に辿り着きました。これから日本空手協会の多くの型動画が少しでも分かるようになれば楽しそうです。中先生の『武道空手の本質とは』は、用語を調べ調べ読み進めたいです。鉄騎の真似事でもなぞらえられるようになりたいです。
実に見事。勉強させて頂きます
MAGNIFICENT, AMAZING, EXCEPTIONAL TECHNIQUE
かっこいい…まさに静と動。攻めてきてる相手がみえた…ような気がする!
素晴らしい‼️
A great thing to see a Master class of tatsuya naka
型が綺麗過ぎて攻めてきた相手が見えた、、気がした
very nice explanation thank you osh
This note is very important, because is very confidence to have a good reaction.
I worked with this way.
Theodoros Athanasopoulos
Oss
波返しのない鉄騎（ナイハンチ）だがすごい迫力
沖縄の空手の達人を検索してください（ナイハンチ）それを見たら（中）の空手はまだ稽古不足と思うはずです。（中）の空手は あくまでもスポーツ空手です。
（中）はナイハンチの意味を知っているのかな？ナイハンチの意味を知らないと思います。迫力にかけている。本物のナイハンチはこんなものではありません
沖縄の空手の達人で検索してください、それを見たら（中）の形はまだまだです
野原ハピド
おまえ何様？
なら中師範と殴り合いしてみたら？
押忍
Thank you very much for the tips and specially for have done it with subtitles in English.
GENIAL!!
Great videos! Thanks for the subtitles, keep doing it :3
Merci beaucoup
Very good
Very nice from wher i can get d v d
😊💕
マスター
I suspect that some of those little 'pointers' in kata [to open the hips], may be considered errors by some of the Old School. Yet unless we are open to new ideas how can we ever expect make progress?
Once you understand the art to a high degree and actively go out to seek the answers, the masters (the real ones) love that you go ahead and make changes. You've already respected the art. Naka-sensei, I feel has already achieved that to a high degree.
Some purists don't know what they're doing and that's why they're stuck in "tradition." With unrealistic training expectations and whatnot.
In this video series, I think that Naka Sensei wanted to show open-mindedness when encountering other styles. He is, of course, tremendously polite and respectful. It’s one thing to open the hip up (change the foot angle) when one is about to step forward into z-d, whereas when stepping laterally and landing in kiba-dachi then changing the foot angle would just require changing it back when one landed...
M Cron Truth be told, the “old school” referred to by Bill is nothing more than a rebranding of the original. Many of the ways we THINK are old school techniques are shallow and new inventions. Yoko-Geri keage, as a sokutou-geri for example? Never done by Funakoshi-sensei. But his students started doing it for training purposes instead of the original, which was the open-hips front-kick to the side, and it stuck
I do think, it is an error indeed. From a Bunkai POV, you MUST turn on the ball, as there is not enough space to open the hip. The opponent is not miles away. You are litteraly glued to him in that moment.
The Kata has 3 movements because it wants to show you the transition from right to left, then from left to right.
Naka-sensei has a very bad habit of wanting to apply Kata to Kumite.
2:05
where can I get the subtitled video in Spanish
こんな力入れてたらおならでそう
のちのネテロである
內部進，定步 稽古
In kumite competition, we will forget any those technic. In kumite competition everyone is just punching each other, dont care about the beautiful movement of Karate. Only in Kata we can enjoy the beautiful movement of Karate including. You can say, "Kata can also used in fight"? Really? Just look at back the Kumite competition video all around the world!
Kumite Competition has little to do with Kata. You could say that you can enter Kumite Competition with the Kata knowledge of a yellow belt easily.
That's because Kata is ment for self defence, which has a completely different movement range than Competition Kumite.
isn't nahachi shodan without moving?
Yes
Comment se casser le dos en pratiquant les katas, en plus pour ne pas être efficace... C'est vraiment triste de voir un haut gradé japonais montrer ca.
Je ne comprends pas. Tu peux expliquer stp?
1人だけってなんか寂しそう...
ゼノ
稽古に楽しさいるの？
寂しくもないと思うよ。
宿題と同じだから。
別に楽しくなさそうというコメントを書いているわけではないんだけど...
寂しさは確かにありますが、周りに人がいない分集中できるので、私はおすすめします。
武術の身体操作が、少しわかってきたようですね。
でも、タメを利かせないように注意してください。
m a 高名な武道家かなんかですか？
まだ武術とは言えませんね、あくまでも空手道だと思います。
誰に意見してるかわかってらっしゃいますか？
脳内空手家かな？
直線的な動きはできていると思う。曲線が出来ていない、直線は誰でも出来るが曲線は難しい、（中）はまだ人に空手をかたるには早すぎる
あなたはご高名な空手家なのですか？
馬鹿すぎて草